F yis all... wrote:Yeah saw them in armagh on paddys day. mental gig place went ballistic!! absolutely spot on as a tribute. Dunno how long they on the go but I see they've a few gigs lined up on their site...
where abouts did they play?
F yis all... wrote:Yeah saw them in armagh on paddys day. mental gig place went ballistic!! absolutely spot on as a tribute. Dunno how long they on the go but I see they've a few gigs lined up on their site...
Pokerface wrote:This is a reply to paddy rolling stone!! If you want to hear a good pogues tribute band in Ireland youre after the wrong tribute. Bhoys from the County Hell are as authentic as they come and im afraid The Rogues dont have a patch on them! First of all the "Shane mac Gowan" of the band with a Dundalk accent palpable in his singing leaves a lot to be desired. Second of all it seems from a recent press release its all about the boozing and whatever else with The Rogues! If you want to hear a passionate, proper and pure legendary pogues tribute band the Bhoys from the County Hell are your band.
Michaelo wrote:I think they're ok. I prefer this to bands like DKM and Flogging Molly- if you're gonna try and copy the Pogues then you may as well try and make it as faithful to the original as you can.
Guest wrote:Michaelo wrote:I think they're ok. I prefer this to bands like DKM and Flogging Molly- if you're gonna try and copy the Pogues then you may as well try and make it as faithful to the original as you can.
Niave argument.
Thats exactly the same weak argument that Noel Hill and other traditional purists said when the Pogues started to tear lumps out of Traditional and Dubliners songs.
With Irish Traditional music, there are no rules anymore. This is mostly down to the Pogues. Its about taking the original and making of it what you want.
philipchevron wrote:Guest wrote:Michaelo wrote:I think they're ok. I prefer this to bands like DKM and Flogging Molly- if you're gonna try and copy the Pogues then you may as well try and make it as faithful to the original as you can.
Niave argument.
Thats exactly the same weak argument that Noel Hill and other traditional purists said when the Pogues started to tear lumps out of Traditional and Dubliners songs.
With Irish Traditional music, there are no rules anymore. This is mostly down to the Pogues. Its about taking the original and making of it what you want.
Oh, there ARE still rules, trust me. Nothing good can come of RIVERDANCE, for example. Or the Cranberries.
philipchevron wrote:Oh, there ARE still rules, trust me. Nothing good can come of RIVERDANCE, for example. Or the Cranberries.
|
Board index » General » Shared Glory All times are UTC |
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests