Hey Everyone,
great to find such an interesting and active forum here...
Sunday at the Orpheum was my 4th Pogues show, after getting snake bit by Shane Shows and Pogues albums in the mid 90's... (i just hit 38 myself for presepctive...) Anyway, as a live music maniac (probably akin to Mr. C's theatre going!("when budget permits and also when it does not!")) i can attest the Pogues are truly a one-of-a-kind live music experience.
Searching out the magic of shared experiences like this is a true joy, and any comments below on Sunday is qualified by all written above.
Personally i find inspiration in all sorts of live music... but for the sake of argument, i'll submit two succinctly different paths of musical expression are employed by most bands/acts i see.
One would be the polished act, with the same banter each night between songs and an almost expected linear format.
Two would be the non-linear, whatever happens, happens, show.
Both can be sublime enchanting and totally fresh each evening.
Both can be predictable, or totally out of the ordinary, regardless of changing or static setlists.
I have a lifetime of musical loves in both categories.
But... were i pressed... there is no question, the seekers of transcendence via a concert should opt for number Two. A band regardless of talent who leaves as much room as they can for audience input each night will find corners a band plowing through their set will not. A possible natural mystic that can sometimes be lost at more prescribed events.
"Sure, sounds great for spinning in hallways at dead shows or closing your eyes to a Van Morrison lyric... but what is your point dude?"
Point is bands like this, bands like the Pogues (to me!) really deserve some slack for making a reach others might not. Not forgiveness, but understanding in their endeavors.
In seeing bands like the Pogues i have noticed the obvious differences night to night, and part of that, or the possibility of that surely brings us back more and more. yeah the dead changed their lists, but even if they didn't the possibility of newness would have been there each an every night.
Of course there is no difference for the Pogues or any band reaching the gap.
Funnily enough there is *some* predictability in these areas, which we are all too familiar with.
And i think we ran into one of them last night... Take your unpredictable band X and put them in a small venue your ears might perk. Take them and put them at a hometown show, again different pre-interest.
It is great trying to do "concert math' with these types of bands to hone in on a winning show. always fun, and always safer just to go to as many as possible!
Anyway specifically, another biggie, and the one i think we found last night, is the post-magic letdown...
When i started reading the reviews of Saturday, it began a slow sinking feeling when thinking of my single Sunday show venture...
Being more wary of places like the Avalon than excited (ie.GA idiots) my heart groaned at my wimpyness and cheered everyone with the balls to go and attempt enjoyment. I knew instantly we were going to be up against it at The Orpheum Sunday...
NOTHING to do with the band no being able to top it, they surely could have...
NOTHING to do with the venue, as i was excited for close reserved seating and had seen the Pogues tear the Orpheum apart in 2006...
EVERYTHING to do with the type of band they are, 'reachers' who, by nature(and thankfully), cannot command the spirit to return at whim.
we would just have to cross our fingers, with the knowledge we missed one hell of a party the night before... here were my takes, and thanks for reading, as i have been thinking about some of your other eloquent posts here...
The Orpheum, March 11th 2007 -
When the lights came down the front of the orchestra was fairly empty and it seemed a little subdued in the building... Cheers were loud but the cohesiveness of the crowd at the outset was not there.
I adore the Clash intro... if that doesn't stir your blood...
right off, it seemed Shane was not to be the shining light he can be, as him and Spider started a night of fitfulness between them as far as i could tell... Shane missing the lyrics of Streams was not as halting as Spider's body language if you ask me... and i am not picking on Spider, he seemed frustrated at from outset and that didn't seem to change. Shane's performance was certainly worthy of frustration at times if there is any truth to what i speak. So a bit of a grumpy, non-cohesive Shane missing lyrics start...
Fans filtered in, but one huge patch of the front orchestra, a patch that i am guessing was 'held back' to be sold after the band/promoter releases them at a time of their choosing... unfortunately they were never sold for whatever reasons... assumably the stretch of 4 shows in BOS quelled demand or idiotic ticket agents. Whatever the reason, it definitely felt icky and hollow to me, so much so i had to to the old 'move up' to at least feel i was part of the crowd, as i was directly behind that empty patch.
things grew looser and the crowd gained collective enthusiasm, and by Kitty-Sayonara-Repeal things were in as full a swing as they would get... Repeal was stellar and the best of the night if you ask me... and this little run made up for the uglier run in front of it, wherein Boys From County Hell, an uber-favorite of mine and Pogue show barometer if you ask me, was just mangled by Shane.
White City and sweet Tuesday Morning eased us out and we were off to a more satifying middle portion of the program... Again i loved Repeal. and in that vain, Thousands Are Sailing dedicated to RFK.
With Shane not on board in the fullest sense, the band and crowd certainly did what they could together and it was certianly an enjoyable evening...
But, back to all the bramble above... I write feeling unsettled in thinking i may not see this band again for some time and just missed Saturday night(ie.any magical Pogues moment) by inches... "what could have been!" Surely they all can't be winners, and that is exactly why i love this band, and respect all in their category, but man, is there a way to shake this feeling?
Write a diatribe to the forum as your first post?
Or, realize you have to be in New Jersey Wednesday, and if you work it just right, maybe, you could squeeze in NYC on Thursday?? are you crazy? are even there tickets left? would you ever have even tried if last night was Saturday instead?
I really don't know... and I like it.
