D18 wrote:Thanks for the reply Phillip, I appreciate it. The guitar's comfort being a main factor in deciding what to use makes a lot of sense. I would think that by the time you mic a guitar, run it through and amp, mic the amp and mix that with the other 7 + guys you're playing with in the Pogues, there's not much left of the guitar's "natural" acoustic sound making it to the audience's ears.
An interesting aside, when taking my son guitar shopping last year, for something with built-in electronics, one of the leaders was a used Takamine. In the end, we decided that - while it sounded fabulously acoustic when amplified - it sounded strangley electro-acoustic when NOT amplified. I understand this is what Christy Moore plays on stage (my son settled on a new Sigma, which was great value and we're both pretty happy with).
D18 wrote:One thing that amazes me about the Pogues is the wall of sound you guys guys create when playing live, there's not a lot of distinction between the rhythm instruments, but the whistle and accordion still stand out when playing a lead. The mix on the Paris DVD is great as it was when I saw you guys play live back in 2007. Mr. Scully does a great job with the notoriously hard to mic instruments used in the Pogues. Preventing feedback at those volumes must be a hell of a challenge.
Yeah, that guy should get an award. If he's not won any, The Pogues should invent one just for him. I've seen bands whose sound goes to hell with the introduction of one 'folk" instrument into the mix, how he balances accordions with guitars and mandolins and whistles and banjo... amazing.