mikalebrug wrote:Question for Mr Chevron,
The liner notes say:
NW3
(1987, previously unreleased) (d)
[S. MacGowan]
Produced by The Pogues
I thought the only recorded version of NW3 was made for the Falconer demos in 1990. Is this an earlier attempt?
Mikael
We first recorded NW3 in 1987, then in 1990. There was a further recording for the Hell's Ditch album, though this was never completed.
Extract from my sleeve note in the box set:
"Some of our songs seemed to follow us around without ever quite finding a home. I think we all felt that "NW 3" was one of Shane's strongest pieces of work and we kept trying to include it in albums but, for reasons that are likely to remain unclear, it was not to be. The version on here [Disc One] is the first recording we have of it, from October 1987, but certainly not the last. By the time we got to working on our fifth album, the Joe Strummer-produced Hell's Ditch, we even finished a strong new backing track of it for that record, but it never got completed. When Shane came down to Rockfield Studios in Wales, he allocated his time there to other ideas - including the remarkable medley of Culture's "I'm Alone in the Wilderness" with his own "Pinned Down" [Disc One]. "
I should add that Shane, fresh back from Thailand with a new outlook on his own independence, not to say song lyrics which attempted to define that independence and his escalating estrangement from his colleagues, was in no mood to submit to the resurrection of old classics. All the same, the half-finished state of pieces like "Aisling" was not necessarily a better option than a "NW 3" that would have required only a vocal line to be considered finished. It remains one of the multiple paradoxes of that album.