Jon wrote:I'm impressed by anyone who can write out this tab thing - I can just about read it.
For Mandolin there's a great site called the Mandolin Cafe at
http://www.mandolincafe.com/ and I'm thinking of buying a banjo this month, but can't decide whether to go for a 5 or 4 string, and if I go for the 4 string, whether I need to tune it the same as my mando or learn a whole load of new chord shapes?
Anyone?
Yeah, Mandolin Cafe is great. I found them before I even got the Mando. It's just a
little unfortunate that it seems to cater more to the Bluegrass or classical croud however moreso than celtic, not that there's anything wrong w/ that, but most of the lessons I've found, lean toward bluegrass.
Because Mandolin is the first instrument I've ever picked up, and I can't even really read music, I really couldn't say definitively whether the Banjo should be tuned like the Mandolin, but if I would hazard to guess, I'd tune them seperately, otherwise one may not ever play the other instrument as it is intended to be played...not that there's anything wrong w/ that. Kinda like it might be important to forget all about Mandolin when learning to play Banjo, otherwise you might just get stuck in a never ending loop of trying to get the banjo to sound like mandolin, but really, what do I know? A reputable dealer should be able to tune it properly in any event.
For all I know, they're basically tuned the same way anyway...or not.
As for writing or reading tablature, for someone who can't
read music, Tab is pretty much intuitive IMO, especially considering it basically looks the same way the strings are laid out. And coming from someone who's mostly using TAB 100%, and I've looked at a lot of it, it goes from very very simple, so very complicated (and I haven't learned to read all of it yet either).
I'm kinda learning to read tab and play by ear, because most of it is so poorly written IMO, that it takes a few tries to make even the correct notes to sound like anything familiar. I am learning to read standard notation too, because it helps to make sense of the more complicated TAB, what with up/down beats, speed, breaks, repeats, etc.
Hopefully in the end, I'll be reading standard notation and forget all about TAB.
Thanks,
Coop