Kilmichael wrote:Santa (i.e. my gorgeous wife) got me the CD as well, loving it, great performance and recording.
Been listening to a lot of the official live Pogues releases recently and one of the things that has struck me is the little differences within each performance of certain songs. This seems to be most obvious on tracks like DOT and Brown Eyes, where what's played on the mandolin and banjo particularly seems to vary between different versions. Does anybody know if this just down to the recording/acoustics/mastering or have certain band members changed or amended their parts over the years on certain songs?
Well, that depends. Arrangements evolve over time in the natural order of things. However, "Dirty Old Town" may be a special case as, in 2001, we abandoned the 1985 arrangement we had worked on with Elvis Costello for
Rum, Sodomy. Elvis felt that because Ewan MacColl's ballad does not shift anywhere else once the main theme has been stated [that is, there is no chorus or middle eight or other harmonic shift] but just repeats to the finish, that a potential single version needed more colour and variation, so he helped us put some key changes in it. Notably, these are right after the guitar/harmonica introductory verse and coming into the uileann pipes/fiddle/mandolin instrumental section later. Almost certainly, EC's commercial judgement was sound on this but, when it came to do the song again for the 2001 reunion, Shane asked us to restore it to how it had been before that, which is basically how the Dubliners had played it before us. Interestingly, this released a whole new energy into the song, a kind of old-timey string band vibe which we all liked very much. This is substantially the version we've stuck with ever since, although of course this in itself varies depending on whether or not the horns are with us - the trombone, sax and trumpet add their own cadences which affect the overall sound.
But in general, as individuals, it's fair to say we're always making small changes in our work all the time. It keeps things interesting.