Wed Apr 27, 2005 6:22 pm
Simon, the rules have changed over the years, from both the Musicians Union and the BBC. On "Fairytale", Shane is obviously miming/chewing gum, whereas Kirsty is miming quite plausibly to her rerecorded vocal (with the arse/ass change). By "Tuesday Morning", TOTP were demanding live lead vocals. On "The Irish Rover", when Spider was away filming in Nicaragua, the Union required that a deputy whistle player be found (I seem to remember Sean Cannon from the Dubliners got the job). And yet, I don't think anyone was bothered that we had no harpist and string orchestra or french horn for "Fairytale". Go figure.
The TOTP studio was such an unpleasant cattleshed for bands and audiences, that we were mostly content to get a little tipsy and mime, treat it as a day out in Elstree. That said, I just got an amazing bootleg DVD of some 60s "live" appearances on German, US and UK telly progs - great performances from Sir Douglas Quintet, Troggs, Vanilla Fudge, Bobby Fuller Four, Standells, Strangeloves, Seeds, Iron Butterfly, Count Five, ? and the Mysterions etc etc. Terrific stuff - inimitable.
On the other hand, recently my other band the Radiators played "Television Screen" on Irish TV and the sound was so terrible, we wished we hadn't bothered.
So I guess the jury is still out on that one.