by Guest Sat Dec 15, 2007 7:23 pm
To be honest, if you think Shane was awful for the whole gig then I'm not quite sure what you were expecting. OK, I'll be honest: he made a mess of Transmetropolitan but the band held it together, and of course If I Should Fall From Grace With God was an utter mess. He didn't just forget the words, he got confused after the first verse and actually started singing Transmetropolan again over the IISFFGWG music, which sounded truly dreadful. Which is why Spider apologised afterwards.
At that point I thought we were in for a long evening, but Shane pulled it together and against the odds sang Broad Majestic Shannon perfectly next up. From there it was good all the way, and it got better and livelier as the night went on. FONY and BFCH were excellent, as were Dirty Old Town, Streams of Whiskey and so on.
Yes, Shane sounded like Shane, and stumbled and mumbled as he always does. But that's what you go for!

All in all, I'd say the second half of the show was great, the first two songs were terrible, and the rest of the first half was pretty good.
I was in the standing/dancing area rather than the seats though so I'm sure that helped the atmosphere. It didn't seem too empty down there, but it might have looked different from the seats. Had I only been able to get a seated ticket I wouldn't have bothered going mind you, it doesn't matter what band you're seeing or whether the venue's packed, there's no atmosphere when you're in a seat anyway.
I'd say have another go next year, but make sure you're standing!!
To be honest, if you think Shane was awful for the whole gig then I'm not quite sure what you were expecting. OK, I'll be honest: he made a mess of Transmetropolitan but the band held it together, and of course If I Should Fall From Grace With God was an utter mess. He didn't just forget the words, he got confused after the first verse and actually started singing Transmetropolan again over the IISFFGWG music, which sounded truly dreadful. Which is why Spider apologised afterwards.
At that point I thought we were in for a long evening, but Shane pulled it together and against the odds sang Broad Majestic Shannon perfectly next up. From there it was good all the way, and it got better and livelier as the night went on. FONY and BFCH were excellent, as were Dirty Old Town, Streams of Whiskey and so on.
Yes, Shane sounded like Shane, and stumbled and mumbled as he always does. But that's what you go for! :) All in all, I'd say the second half of the show was great, the first two songs were terrible, and the rest of the first half was pretty good.
I was in the standing/dancing area rather than the seats though so I'm sure that helped the atmosphere. It didn't seem too empty down there, but it might have looked different from the seats. Had I only been able to get a seated ticket I wouldn't have bothered going mind you, it doesn't matter what band you're seeing or whether the venue's packed, there's no atmosphere when you're in a seat anyway.
I'd say have another go next year, but make sure you're standing!!