Skip to content


Advanced search
  • Board index ‹ General ‹ Shared Glory
  • Syndication
  • Change font size
  • FAQ
  • Members
  • Register
  • Login

"Three Irish Tenors" version of Fairytale

Post a reply

Question Which do you wear on your feet: shoes, gloves, scarf:
This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.
Smilies
:D :) :( :o :shock: :? 8) :lol: :x :P :oops: :cry: :evil: :twisted: :roll: :wink: :!: :?: :idea: :arrow: :| :mrgreen:
BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[flash] is OFF
[url] is ON
Smilies are ON
Topic review
   
  • Options

Expand view Topic review: "Three Irish Tenors" version of Fairytale

  • Quote Zuzana

Post by Zuzana Wed Nov 17, 2004 12:16 pm

Could anyone post the Irish Tenors' lyrics here? I mean those passages which differ from the Pogues' version. I'd love to see how the dignified gentlemen coped with the „ticklish“ lines.
Could anyone post the Irish Tenors' lyrics here? I mean those passages which differ from the Pogues' version. I'd love to see how the dignified gentlemen coped with the „ticklish“ lines.
  • Quote Maija

Post by Maija Wed Nov 17, 2004 8:26 am

Ehm, I love the Pogues for their music... for their rawness and their capability of sometimes describe hell on earth in the same breath that they sing about boozin' and screwin' (or all three mixed into one).

I have my doubts that some classically trained singers can convey the same. Don't misunderstand me, I do love classical music, but making classical (or pan flute! *gag*) versions of rock just doesn't seem like a good idea for me! The classical version of Rammstein's Mein Herz brennt didn't exactly do it for me either.
Ehm, I love the Pogues for their music... for their rawness and their capability of sometimes describe hell on earth in the same breath that they sing about boozin' and screwin' (or all three mixed into one).

I have my doubts that some classically trained singers can convey the same. Don't misunderstand me, I do love classical music, but making classical (or pan flute! *gag*) versions of rock just doesn't seem like a good idea for me! The classical version of Rammstein's Mein Herz brennt didn't exactly do it for me either.
  • Quote Irishman

Post by Irishman Wed Nov 17, 2004 2:39 am

the irish tenors are kickass
the irish tenors are kickass
  • Quote DaBanjo

Post by DaBanjo Sun Apr 11, 2004 12:54 pm

The tenors have completely excised any of the harsher lyrics. As a result, it's a much, much different song.
The tenors have completely excised any of the harsher lyrics. As a result, it's a much, much different song.
  • Quote DzM

Post by DzM Fri Apr 09, 2004 11:52 pm

Samples are here and here.

The Amazon.com paid reviewer had this to say:<blockquote><blockquote type=cite>There's a commercial inevitability to holiday song collections that can tempt music fans to mutter "humbug" under their breath. Yet while this
collection (released in conjunction with the Tenors' Christmas
Spectacular tour of 2003) is no less market savvy, in the end the trio's
earnest, energetic performances earn their fair shair of respect. The
trio's Celtic shadings impart considerable warmth to "Fairytale of New
York" and other performances, but it's the range of influences they
(also in solo and duet turns, all solidly backed by the Czech National
Chamber Orchestra) bring to bear elsewhere that adds compelling new
dimensions to these holiday favorites. Anthony Kearns' "It Came Upon a
Midnight Clear" may be solidly traditional, but Ronan Tynan imparts
"I'll Be Home For Christmas" with some deft, jazzy drama while Finbar
Wright gives "Mary's Boy Child" an unexpected Carribean spin. Elsewhere,
the folk-classical influences behind "We Three Kings," "O Holy Night,"
and the gospel traditional "How Great Thou Art" span renaissance,
baroque, and modern with a grace missing from the on-the-sleeve
sentiments of the closing duo of patriotic warhorses--what would the
Prince of Peace make of "The Battle Hymn of the Republic," anyway?
--Jerry McCulley</blockquote></blockquote>And some customer said this about it:<blockquote><blockquote type=cite>***** We Three Kings, December 5, 2003
Reviewer: A music fan from United States
This is an incredible CD, much better than the first Irish Tenors CD, probably because Finbar Wright is a much better singer than McDermott. Personally the highlights of the album for me are the solos and duets by Anthony Kearns. The Lord's Prayer stands out from all the others. On the lighter side is Fairytale of New York. I would definitely recommend this CD for anyone.</blockquote></blockquote>"On the lighter side is Fairytale of New York"? Have they actually listened to the lyrics? Or have the tenors mangled them such that it's a charming story of Christmas Joy in New York?
Samples are [url=http://mfile.akamai.com/2851/rm/razntie.download.akamai.com/2851/MS2897_01_04_H.ram]here[/url] and [url=http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/clipserve/B0000D9PST001004/1/002-1636680-7287256]here[/url].

The Amazon.com paid reviewer had this to say:<blockquote><blockquote type=cite>There's a commercial inevitability to holiday song collections that can tempt music fans to mutter "humbug" under their breath. Yet while this
collection (released in conjunction with the Tenors' Christmas
Spectacular tour of 2003) is no less market savvy, in the end the trio's
earnest, energetic performances earn their fair shair of respect. The
trio's Celtic shadings impart considerable warmth to "Fairytale of New
York" and other performances, but it's the range of influences they
(also in solo and duet turns, all solidly backed by the Czech National
Chamber Orchestra) bring to bear elsewhere that adds compelling new
dimensions to these holiday favorites. Anthony Kearns' "It Came Upon a
Midnight Clear" may be solidly traditional, but Ronan Tynan imparts
"I'll Be Home For Christmas" with some deft, jazzy drama while Finbar
Wright gives "Mary's Boy Child" an unexpected Carribean spin. Elsewhere,
the folk-classical influences behind "We Three Kings," "O Holy Night,"
and the gospel traditional "How Great Thou Art" span renaissance,
baroque, and modern with a grace missing from the on-the-sleeve
sentiments of the closing duo of patriotic warhorses--what would the
Prince of Peace make of "The Battle Hymn of the Republic," anyway?
--Jerry McCulley</blockquote></blockquote>And some customer said this about it:<blockquote><blockquote type=cite>***** We Three Kings, December 5, 2003
Reviewer: A music fan from United States
This is an incredible CD, much better than the first Irish Tenors CD, probably because Finbar Wright is a much better singer than McDermott. Personally the highlights of the album for me are the solos and duets by Anthony Kearns. The Lord's Prayer stands out from all the others. On the lighter side is Fairytale of New York. I would definitely recommend this CD for anyone.</blockquote></blockquote>"On the lighter side is Fairytale of New York"? Have they actually listened to the lyrics? Or have the tenors mangled them such that it's a charming story of Christmas Joy in New York?
  • Quote DaBanjo

"Three Irish Tenors" version of Fairytale

Post by DaBanjo Fri Apr 09, 2004 11:33 pm

Just hear the "Three Irish Tenors" version of Fairytale of New York. One of the funniest Pogues covers you'll ever hear. Cleaned up lyrics, seasonal lyrical embellishments.

Making Shane MacGowan safe for your grandmother.
Just hear the "Three Irish Tenors" version of Fairytale of New York. One of the funniest Pogues covers you'll ever hear. Cleaned up lyrics, seasonal lyrical embellishments.

Making Shane MacGowan safe for your grandmother.

Top

  • Board index
  • The team • Delete all board cookies • All times are UTC


Powered by phpBB
Content © copyright the original authors unless otherwise indicated