Skip to content


Advanced search
  • Board index ‹ Outside The Pogues ‹ Shane MacGowan
  • Syndication
  • Change font size
  • FAQ
  • Members
  • Register
  • Login

Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post a reply

Question Which do you wear on your feet: shoes, gloves, scarf:
This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.
Smilies
:D :) :( :o :shock: :? 8) :lol: :x :P :oops: :cry: :evil: :twisted: :roll: :wink: :!: :?: :idea: :arrow: :| :mrgreen:
BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[flash] is OFF
[url] is ON
Smilies are ON
Topic review
   
  • Options

Expand view Topic review: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

  • Quote Nat999

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by Nat999 Wed Dec 01, 2010 9:05 pm

This song has the good ol' dirty sound that I like. It gives me goosebumps. There's so many versions of this song but I'm sure that this is one of the best that I've ever heard. It's a shame that it didn't get more popular...
This song has the good ol' dirty sound that I like. It gives me goosebumps. There's so many versions of this song but I'm sure that this is one of the best that I've ever heard. It's a shame that it didn't get more popular...
  • Quote Low D

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by Low D Sat Jul 24, 2010 5:03 pm

philipchevron wrote: all of them had limited edition promo editions to make life simpler for radio programmers.


I do have such a pressing of another download-only single (Booker T. & Jolie Holland - Wonderful World/Blessing), also purchased over ebay, so it's certainly possible.
[quote="philipchevron"] all of them had limited edition promo editions to make life simpler for radio programmers. [/quote]

I do have such a pressing of another download-only single (Booker T. & Jolie Holland - [i]Wonderful World/Blessing)[/i], also purchased over ebay, so it's certainly possible.
  • Quote James

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by James Fri Jul 23, 2010 11:27 pm

Smerker wrote:
John C wrote:
Smerker wrote:I think there must be material dating back to the original 20th Century Paddy sessions.


Nope. No such material exists.


EVERY REPORTER EVER: Hey, Shane, how about new material? You working hard?
SHANE: Oh, yeah, 'course, yeah. Like, er, yeah. Um. Every song's gonna have "paddy" in the title. And Rick Rubin's... an okay producer, isn't he?

Do you mean it was never recorded, or that there's been no new songs since The Crock? What's your source there?


Yeah, there's nothing happening, is there?
[quote="Smerker"][quote="John C"][quote="Smerker"]I think there must be material dating back to the original 20th Century Paddy sessions.[/quote]

Nope. No such material exists.[/quote]

EVERY REPORTER EVER: Hey, Shane, how about new material? You working hard?
SHANE: Oh, yeah, 'course, yeah. Like, er, yeah. Um. Every song's gonna have "paddy" in the title. And Rick Rubin's... an okay producer, isn't he?

Do you mean it was never recorded, or that there's been no new songs since [i]The Crock[/i]? What's your source there?[/quote]

Yeah, there's nothing happening, is there?
  • Quote in_the_morning

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by in_the_morning Thu Jul 22, 2010 10:38 pm

What a shame that this never got big...it was the best charity record for Haiti by far....so many talents on one record organized by Shane and his missus....but there it is....most of the people out there seem to enjoy listening to crap...it's really ridicolous but that's the way it is :?
What a shame that this never got big...it was the best charity record for Haiti by far....so many talents on one record organized by Shane and his missus....but there it is....most of the people out there seem to enjoy listening to crap...it's really ridicolous but that's the way it is :?
  • Quote philipchevron

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by philipchevron Mon Jun 28, 2010 10:11 pm

DzM wrote:
philipchevron wrote:
DzM wrote:There was no physical distribution of the song. The cost of producing physical media was cited as the reason. "We'd rather apply that money to helping the people of Haiti."

Looks like someone is just trying to make a buck off of somebody else's charity single. Classy.


Well, that's certainly possible, though I'm more inclined to the idea that this is some sort of limited promo CD designed to attract airplay or whatever. However, as I have no desire to inflate the auction price either way, I must stress that I don't actually know this to be the case.

Very true, and I should stress that I Don't Know Anything. Where I got my info was here:

http://www.concern.net/blogs/posts/song-haiti

Submitted by Caryne (not verified) on 1 March, 2010 - 14:31.
Is this going to be available as a real record? I just don't do downloads :-(

Submitted by Niall O Murchu on 1 March, 2010 - 18:00.
It is available as a download only, I'm afraid.


Niall appears to be a Concern.net guy.


Indeed, though if I were a Concern guy, I too would be denying all knowledge of solid hard copies of the recording to Shane MacGowan fans when my heart was set on all those lovely download figures. Singles off the Radiators Trouble Pilgrim album and Horslips Roll Back album - for example - were not commercially available except as downloads but all of them had limited edition promo editions to make life simpler for radio programmers. In part, it's a consequence of the main market being an island nation of less than 5 million people. This explains why Irish pressings of old vinyl singles can be quite collectible.
[quote="DzM"][quote="philipchevron"][quote="DzM"]There was no physical distribution of the song. The cost of producing physical media was cited as the reason. "We'd rather apply that money to helping the people of Haiti."

Looks like someone is just trying to make a buck off of somebody else's charity single. Classy.[/quote]

Well, that's certainly possible, though I'm more inclined to the idea that this is some sort of limited promo CD designed to attract airplay or whatever. However, as I have no desire to inflate the auction price either way, I must stress that I don't actually [i]know[/i] this to be the case.[/quote]
Very true, and I should stress that I Don't Know Anything. Where I got my info was here:

http://www.concern.net/blogs/posts/song-haiti

[quote]Submitted by Caryne (not verified) on 1 March, 2010 - 14:31.
Is this going to be available as a real record? I just don't do downloads :-(

Submitted by Niall O Murchu on 1 March, 2010 - 18:00.
It is available as a download only, I'm afraid.[/quote]

Niall appears to be a Concern.net guy.[/quote]

Indeed, though if I were a Concern guy, I too would be denying all knowledge of solid hard copies of the recording to Shane MacGowan fans when my heart was set on all those lovely download figures. Singles off the Radiators [i]Trouble Pilgrim[/i] album and Horslips [i]Roll Back[/i] album - for example - were not commercially available except as downloads but all of them had limited edition promo editions to make life simpler for radio programmers. In part, it's a consequence of the main market being an island nation of less than 5 million people. This explains why Irish pressings of old vinyl singles can be quite collectible.
  • Quote DzM

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by DzM Mon Jun 28, 2010 9:47 pm

philipchevron wrote:
DzM wrote:There was no physical distribution of the song. The cost of producing physical media was cited as the reason. "We'd rather apply that money to helping the people of Haiti."

Looks like someone is just trying to make a buck off of somebody else's charity single. Classy.


Well, that's certainly possible, though I'm more inclined to the idea that this is some sort of limited promo CD designed to attract airplay or whatever. However, as I have no desire to inflate the auction price either way, I must stress that I don't actually know this to be the case.

Very true, and I should stress that I Don't Know Anything. Where I got my info was here:

http://www.concern.net/blogs/posts/song-haiti

Submitted by Caryne (not verified) on 1 March, 2010 - 14:31.
Is this going to be available as a real record? I just don't do downloads :-(

Submitted by Niall O Murchu on 1 March, 2010 - 18:00.
It is available as a download only, I'm afraid.


Niall appears to be a Concern.net guy.
[quote="philipchevron"][quote="DzM"]There was no physical distribution of the song. The cost of producing physical media was cited as the reason. "We'd rather apply that money to helping the people of Haiti."

Looks like someone is just trying to make a buck off of somebody else's charity single. Classy.[/quote]

Well, that's certainly possible, though I'm more inclined to the idea that this is some sort of limited promo CD designed to attract airplay or whatever. However, as I have no desire to inflate the auction price either way, I must stress that I don't actually [i]know[/i] this to be the case.[/quote]
Very true, and I should stress that I Don't Know Anything. Where I got my info was here:

http://www.concern.net/blogs/posts/song-haiti

[quote]Submitted by Caryne (not verified) on 1 March, 2010 - 14:31.
Is this going to be available as a real record? I just don't do downloads :-(

Submitted by Niall O Murchu on 1 March, 2010 - 18:00.
It is available as a download only, I'm afraid.[/quote]

Niall appears to be a Concern.net guy.
  • Quote philipchevron

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by philipchevron Mon Jun 28, 2010 9:41 pm

DzM wrote:There was no physical distribution of the song. The cost of producing physical media was cited as the reason. "We'd rather apply that money to helping the people of Haiti."

Looks like someone is just trying to make a buck off of somebody else's charity single. Classy.


Well, that's certainly possible, though I'm more inclined to the idea that this is some sort of limited promo CD designed to attract airplay or whatever. However, as I have no desire to inflate the auction price either way, I must stress that I don't actually know this to be the case.
[quote="DzM"]There was no physical distribution of the song. The cost of producing physical media was cited as the reason. "We'd rather apply that money to helping the people of Haiti."

Looks like someone is just trying to make a buck off of somebody else's charity single. Classy.[/quote]

Well, that's certainly possible, though I'm more inclined to the idea that this is some sort of limited promo CD designed to attract airplay or whatever. However, as I have no desire to inflate the auction price either way, I must stress that I don't actually [i]know[/i] this to be the case.
  • Quote DzM

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by DzM Mon Jun 28, 2010 7:06 pm

There was no physical distribution of the song. The cost of producing physical media was cited as the reason. "We'd rather apply that money to helping the people of Haiti."

Looks like someone is just trying to make a buck off of somebody else's charity single. Classy.
There was no physical distribution of the song. The cost of producing physical media was cited as the reason. "We'd rather apply that money to helping the people of Haiti."

Looks like someone is just trying to make a buck off of somebody else's charity single. Classy.
  • Quote RoddyRuddy

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by RoddyRuddy Mon Jun 28, 2010 6:42 pm

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll? ... 0448186354

Seen a cd version of the Hati song up for sale on ebay .
Is this an offical cd release or is someone cashing in a download only charity song ?
Would hope some of the money would go to Concern , as Iam sure Shane intended .
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=290448186354

Seen a cd version of the Hati song up for sale on ebay .
Is this an offical cd release or is someone cashing in a download only charity song ?
Would hope some of the money would go to Concern , as Iam sure Shane intended .
  • Quote Fr. McGreer

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by Fr. McGreer Wed Apr 07, 2010 10:31 pm

philipchevron wrote:
Fr. McGreer wrote: I DJ at an 80's club night and if i play The Smiths 75% of the dance floor will empty. If i play Tight Fit, The Lion Sleeps Tonight, dance floor jammed. Fucking frustrating.


You're doing it wrong. Supply the punters with free gladioli and watch them sway! 8)


:lol: :lol: And maybe the odd hearing aid.
[quote="philipchevron"][quote="Fr. McGreer"] I DJ at an 80's club night and if i play The Smiths 75% of the dance floor will empty. If i play Tight Fit, The Lion Sleeps Tonight, dance floor jammed. Fucking frustrating.[/quote]

You're doing it wrong. Supply the punters with free gladioli and watch them sway! 8)[/quote]

:lol: :lol: And maybe the odd hearing aid.
  • Quote philipchevron

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by philipchevron Wed Apr 07, 2010 10:27 pm

Fr. McGreer wrote: I DJ at an 80's club night and if i play The Smiths 75% of the dance floor will empty. If i play Tight Fit, The Lion Sleeps Tonight, dance floor jammed. Fucking frustrating.


You're doing it wrong. Supply the punters with free gladioli and watch them sway! 8)
[quote="Fr. McGreer"] I DJ at an 80's club night and if i play The Smiths 75% of the dance floor will empty. If i play Tight Fit, The Lion Sleeps Tonight, dance floor jammed. Fucking frustrating.[/quote]

You're doing it wrong. Supply the punters with free gladioli and watch them sway! 8)
  • Quote Fr. McGreer

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by Fr. McGreer Wed Apr 07, 2010 10:10 pm

Radio play of this single was absolutely ZERO here in Ireland. I listen to the radio a lot during the day and to a range of stations depending on mood. Not once was the single mentioned in passing or in any way promoted. I don't know whether the single would be considered 'Irish' in as much as say a U2 release would be, but this fact is important because the national music radio stations are compelled to play 25% 'Irish' content.

Shane is a bit of a square peg in a round hole as regards his perceived nationality. Those in the UK would say he's Irish, so why would they get behind him? and here in Ireland he's considered a kind of 'Plastic Paddy' (God, i HATE that term) so again, no real feeling of "Yeah, let's support OUR Man". The only country that mattered as regards chart position was the UK (same as Fairytale).

We (fans and muso's :roll: ) all thought it was "cool" that Shane and Friends covered a relatively obscure classic track and did a mighty fine version of it too. But it just passed the general public by. They sent their few pounds to Haiti in countless other ways.

DzM used his baseball analagy, here's mine..... Just because it's good music does not mean it's popular. I DJ at an 80's club night and if i play The Smiths 75% of the dance floor will empty. If i play Tight Fit, The Lion Sleeps Tonight, dance floor jammed. Fucking frustrating.
Radio play of this single was absolutely ZERO here in Ireland. I listen to the radio a lot during the day and to a range of stations depending on mood. Not once was the single mentioned in passing or in any way promoted. I don't know whether the single would be considered 'Irish' in as much as say a U2 release would be, but this fact is important because the national music radio stations are compelled to play 25% 'Irish' content.

Shane is a bit of a square peg in a round hole as regards his perceived nationality. Those in the UK would say he's Irish, so why would they get behind him? and here in Ireland he's considered a kind of 'Plastic Paddy' (God, i HATE that term) so again, no real feeling of "Yeah, let's support OUR Man". The only country that mattered as regards chart position was the UK (same as Fairytale).

We (fans and muso's :roll: ) all thought it was "cool" that Shane and Friends covered a relatively obscure classic track and did a mighty fine version of it too. But it just passed the general public by. They sent their few pounds to Haiti in countless other ways.

DzM used his baseball analagy, here's mine..... Just because it's good music does not mean it's popular. I DJ at an 80's club night and if i play The Smiths 75% of the dance floor will empty. If i play Tight Fit, The Lion Sleeps Tonight, dance floor jammed. Fucking frustrating.
  • Quote philipchevron

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by philipchevron Wed Apr 07, 2010 10:07 pm

DzM wrote:That's a real shame, and not just because of this single. It really means that the Music Industry(TM) has fallen victim to the movie industry mindset of Blockbusters and has largely forgotten about how to build a loyal following with steady income and run-rates.


It's a great analogy. Remember sleeper hits? Yup, me too.
[quote="DzM"]That's a real shame, and not just because of this single. It really means that the Music Industry(TM) has fallen victim to the movie industry mindset of Blockbusters and has largely forgotten about how to build a loyal following with steady income and run-rates.
[/quote]

It's a great analogy. Remember sleeper hits? Yup, me too.
  • Quote Guest

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by Guest Wed Apr 07, 2010 9:06 pm

lets face it the MAIN reason it was released wasnt to help the haitiens but to help victoria and shane become a bit more famous...
lets face it the MAIN reason it was released wasnt to help the haitiens but to help victoria and shane become a bit more famous...
  • Quote DownInTheGround

Re: Shane Covers I Put A Spell On You For Haiti

Post by DownInTheGround Wed Apr 07, 2010 6:42 pm

DzM wrote:I'm surprised at how quickly this has fallen off the world's radar. After the first few weeks of release the Facebook group appears to be moribund, IRL & Victoria & Siobhan seem to have stopped promoting it, etc. There's no talk of sustaining a chart position, of garnering "celebrity tweets," of a "friendly competition between the singles, with the Haitians winning," etc.

Perhaps this is just showing my lack of experience with how a single is released and promoted, but it seems really odd that a charity single would be considered exhausted and defunct after its first week. Shouldn't there be a constant ongoing effort to get this (and the other charity singles) in front of people? Shouldn't there be a small effort spent to extend the long tail as long as possible? I get the impression that this is not the case. What appears to be done is to push a release out the door with much fanfare and then immediately drop it off a cliff. Is this REALLY how the music and charity industries are run? Am I missing the constant drum-beat of promotion that is happening elsewhere in the world?


As much as I hate to say it, I fear the time between the Haiti Disaster and the release of the single may have just been too long. The Western record buying public does not have a long memory when it comes to disasters in non-English speaking parts of the world. I hope I am wrong

The only play of the song I heard on the radio was on Jarvis Cocker's BBC 6 Music show, and its lack of airplay is surely the reason for its failure. Either way, we got to hear a great cover of a great song, and help the poor people of Haiti in some tiny way, which must mean something.
[quote="DzM"]I'm surprised at how quickly this has fallen off the world's radar. After the first few weeks of release the Facebook group appears to be moribund, IRL & Victoria & Siobhan seem to have stopped promoting it, etc. There's no talk of sustaining a chart position, of garnering "celebrity tweets," of a "friendly competition between the singles, with the Haitians winning," etc.

Perhaps this is just showing my lack of experience with how a single is released and promoted, but it seems really odd that a charity single would be considered exhausted and defunct after its first week. Shouldn't there be a constant ongoing effort to get this (and the other charity singles) in front of people? Shouldn't there be a small effort spent to extend the long tail as long as possible? I get the impression that this is not the case. What appears to be done is to push a release out the door with much fanfare and then immediately drop it off a cliff. Is this REALLY how the music and charity industries are run? Am I missing the constant drum-beat of promotion that is happening elsewhere in the world?[/quote]

As much as I hate to say it, I fear the time between the Haiti Disaster and the release of the single may have just been too long. The Western record buying public does not have a long memory when it comes to disasters in non-English speaking parts of the world. I hope I am wrong

The only play of the song I heard on the radio was on Jarvis Cocker's BBC 6 Music show, and its lack of airplay is surely the reason for its failure. Either way, we got to hear a great cover of a great song, and help the poor people of Haiti in some tiny way, which must mean something.

Top

  • Board index
  • The team • Delete all board cookies • All times are UTC


Powered by phpBB
Content © copyright the original authors unless otherwise indicated