Skip to content


Advanced search
  • Board index ‹ The Pogues ‹ Official music
  • Syndication
  • Change font size
  • FAQ
  • Members
  • Register
  • Login

can shane play banjo

Post a reply

Question Which do you wear on your feet: shoes, gloves, scarf:
This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.
Smilies
:D :) :( :o :shock: :? 8) :lol: :x :P :oops: :cry: :evil: :twisted: :roll: :wink: :!: :?: :idea: :arrow: :| :mrgreen:
BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[flash] is OFF
[url] is ON
Smilies are ON
Topic review
   
  • Options

Expand view Topic review: can shane play banjo

  • Quote The Duke of Ingmar

Post by The Duke of Ingmar Sat Feb 24, 2007 7:35 am

Grievous Angel wrote:The liner notes of Steve Earle's "Copperhead Road" have him credited as playing both banjo and bodhran, and that must have been some trick to play both at the same time.


It´s maybe something only Shane is capable of doing. :D
[quote="Grievous Angel"]The liner notes of Steve Earle's "Copperhead Road" have him credited as playing both banjo and bodhran, and that must have been some trick to play both at the same time.[/quote]

It´s maybe something only Shane is capable of doing. :D
  • Quote Grievous Angel

Post by Grievous Angel Fri Feb 23, 2007 4:37 pm

The liner notes of Steve Earle's "Copperhead Road" have him credited as playing both banjo and bodhran, and that must have been some trick to play both at the same time.
The liner notes of Steve Earle's "Copperhead Road" have him credited as playing both banjo and bodhran, and that must have been some trick to play both at the same time.
  • Quote The Duke of Ingmar

Post by The Duke of Ingmar Fri Feb 23, 2007 3:43 pm

Well, yes, Shane can be seen playing banjo along to "Johnny come lately". But does anyone know whether his "input" got actually recorded ? :wink:
Well, yes, Shane can be seen playing banjo along to "Johnny come lately". But does anyone know whether his "input" got actually recorded ? :wink:
  • Quote MacRua

Post by MacRua Fri Feb 23, 2007 9:28 am

Eckhard wrote:
philipchevron wrote:Can Shane play the banjo? It remains one of the great metaphysical questions of the age. Not even Tony Brown, Steve Earle's producer then and one of the most powerful people in Nashville now, was able to give a definitive answer.


Is that the recording session that can be seen on the "Completely Pogues"-Video you are talking about, Phil?

I would say it's rather about Steve's Copperhead Road and Shane's take on Johnny Come Lately in particular.
[quote="Eckhard"][quote="philipchevron"]Can Shane play the banjo? It remains one of the great metaphysical questions of the age. Not even Tony Brown, Steve Earle's producer then and one of the most powerful people in Nashville now, was able to give a definitive answer.[/quote]

Is that the recording session that can be seen on the "Completely Pogues"-Video you are talking about, Phil?[/quote]
I would say it's rather about Steve's [i]Copperhead Road[/i] and Shane's take on [i]Johnny Come Lately[/i] in particular.
  • Quote Behan

Post by Behan Fri Feb 23, 2007 4:29 am

Eric V wrote:I could swear I saw a vid on utube with Shane playing banjo. And, in general, I believe Shane can play just about anything in order to write a song.


At some shows I had gone to in the 80's, I noticed Shane with a banjo and once with a "Squire" electric guitar. Both instruments were not plugged into anything. :wink:
[quote="Eric V"]I could swear I saw a vid on utube with Shane playing banjo. And, in general, I believe Shane can play just about anything in order to write a song.[/quote]

At some shows I had gone to in the 80's, I noticed Shane with a banjo and once with a "Squire" electric guitar. Both instruments were not plugged into anything. :wink:
  • Quote philipchevron

Post by philipchevron Thu Feb 22, 2007 9:11 pm

Noel Kenny wrote:Another great metaphysical question: Did Mr C ever repay the loan he got for the taxi?


It was not the Pogues' custom to repay loans advanced by wealthier people. We figured if they were working with us they were bound to get even wealthier anyway.
[quote="Noel Kenny"]Another great metaphysical question: Did Mr C ever repay the loan he got for the taxi?[/quote]

It was not the Pogues' custom to repay loans advanced by wealthier people. We figured if they were working with us they were bound to get even wealthier anyway.
  • Quote Noel Kenny

Post by Noel Kenny Thu Feb 22, 2007 8:17 pm

Another great metaphysical question: Did Mr C ever repay the loan he got for the taxi?
Another great metaphysical question: Did Mr C ever repay the loan he got for the taxi?
  • Quote Eckhard

Post by Eckhard Thu Feb 22, 2007 7:52 pm

philipchevron wrote:Can Shane play the banjo? It remains one of the great metaphysical questions of the age. Not even Tony Brown, Steve Earle's producer then and one of the most powerful people in Nashville now, was able to give a definitive answer.


Is that the recording session that can be seen on the "Completely Pogues"-Video you are talking about, Phil?
[quote="philipchevron"]Can Shane play the banjo? It remains one of the great metaphysical questions of the age. Not even Tony Brown, Steve Earle's producer then and one of the most powerful people in Nashville now, was able to give a definitive answer.[/quote]

Is that the recording session that can be seen on the "Completely Pogues"-Video you are talking about, Phil?
  • Quote philipchevron

Post by philipchevron Thu Feb 22, 2007 4:57 pm

Can Shane play the banjo? It remains one of the great metaphysical questions of the age. Not even Tony Brown, Steve Earle's producer then and one of the most powerful people in Nashville now, was able to give a definitive answer.
Can Shane play the banjo? It remains one of the great metaphysical questions of the age. Not even Tony Brown, Steve Earle's producer then and one of the most powerful people in Nashville now, was able to give a definitive answer.
  • Quote pogues24

Post by pogues24 Thu Feb 22, 2007 2:21 pm

Also, if you have a copy of the Completely Pogued documentary that was filmed around 1988, Shane can be seen playing banjo in the studio, when The Pogues are recording Johnny Come Lately with Steve Earle.

Iain
Also, if you have a copy of the Completely Pogued documentary that was filmed around 1988, Shane can be seen playing banjo in the studio, when The Pogues are recording Johnny Come Lately with Steve Earle.

Iain
  • Quote MacRua

Post by MacRua Thu Feb 22, 2007 1:15 pm

you see! that's the difference between usual person and true Artist. Usual guy having got really angry starts playing gun...
you see! that's the difference between usual person and true Artist. Usual guy having got really angry starts playing gun...
  • Quote Fionn MacCool

Post by Fionn MacCool Thu Feb 22, 2007 12:32 pm

MacRua wrote:Then I got really angry and
started playing the bazuka.

:shock:
[quote="MacRua"]Then I got really angry and
started playing the bazuka.[/quote]
:shock:
  • Quote MacRua

Post by MacRua Thu Feb 22, 2007 11:20 am

"Yes, it was my idea [beer tray] . I would’ve done it myself but I was
playing guitar. I stopped palying guitar cause it was difficult to
sing and keep time on the guitar – to sing such intense songs – with
the sound we had in those days, which was very bad. I was putting off
Andy Ranken on the drums a lot of time, you know what I mean. I am a
good rhythm quitarist, but I can’t sing and play guitar at the same
time. So they sacked me from playing the guitar <…> I offered to play
beer tray , cause I didn’t want to stand and just sing, you know what
I mean. I’m a musician. So I offered to play beer tray, but democracy
decided that we had outgrown the beer tray <…> I took up bodhran, and
I played it perfectly well. I mean after being sacked on guitar, I
wasn’t into just standing there singing. I didn’t want to do all rock
and roll poses and jump around either <…> So I started playing the
bodhran. I played it for a year. I use to break one particularly every
night. Eventually… <…> The bodhran got phased out, because they had
decided that I wasn’t playing it well enough. <…> I was quite serious
about it, you know. But the democracy, in the end, decided I wasn’t
allowed to play the bodhran any more. Then I got really angry and
started playing the bazuka. Had another go at rhythm guitar, for a
while. Then I started playing the banjo which really pissed off Jem,
who was the banjo player. I started playing rhythm banjo, and I did it
perfectly well. But they all… for some reason got phased out. In the
end I played Casio on stage, this was when I really didn’t give a fuck
any more<…> So I used to play Casio which made gun noises. And in the
middle of solos by Terry Woods or Jem or whoever, I would start making
gun noises, and fucking plaing out of the key and all the rest of it.
Obviously the democracy didn’t put it up with that for very long."
-- Shane MacGowan. A Drink With Shane MacGowan. Act Five.
"Yes, it was my idea [beer tray] . I would’ve done it myself but I was
playing guitar. I stopped palying guitar cause it was difficult to
sing and keep time on the guitar – to sing such intense songs – with
the sound we had in those days, which was very bad. I was putting off
Andy Ranken on the drums a lot of time, you know what I mean. I am a
good rhythm quitarist, but I can’t sing and play guitar at the same
time. So they sacked me from playing the guitar <…> I offered to play
beer tray , cause I didn’t want to stand and just sing, you know what
I mean. I’m a musician. So I offered to play beer tray, but democracy
decided that we had outgrown the beer tray <…> I took up bodhran, and
I played it perfectly well. I mean after being sacked on guitar, I
wasn’t into just standing there singing. I didn’t want to do all rock
and roll poses and jump around either <…> So I started playing the
bodhran. I played it for a year. I use to break one particularly every
night. Eventually… <…> The bodhran got phased out, because they had
decided that I wasn’t playing it well enough. <…> I was quite serious
about it, you know. But the democracy, in the end, decided I wasn’t
allowed to play the bodhran any more. Then I got really angry and
started playing the bazuka. Had another go at rhythm guitar, for a
while. Then I started playing the banjo which really pissed off Jem,
who was the banjo player. I started playing rhythm banjo, and I did it
perfectly well. But they all… for some reason got phased out. In the
end I played Casio on stage, this was when I really didn’t give a fuck
any more<…> So I used to play Casio which made gun noises. And in the
middle of solos by Terry Woods or Jem or whoever, I would start making
gun noises, and fucking plaing out of the key and all the rest of it.
Obviously the democracy didn’t put it up with that for very long."
-- [i]Shane MacGowan. A Drink With Shane MacGowan. Act Five.[/i]
  • Quote Billie

Post by Billie Thu Feb 22, 2007 10:59 am

on the Town and Country club DVD there's some songs in which Shane plays banjo. I read somewhere he could play bouzuki and wrote "Shanne Bradley" on it, but I can't be sure I'm remembering right. Maybe that was the IISFFGWG booklet saying that.
on the Town and Country club DVD there's some songs in which Shane plays banjo. I read somewhere he could play bouzuki and wrote "Shanne Bradley" on it, but I can't be sure I'm remembering right. Maybe that was the IISFFGWG booklet saying that.
  • Quote Zuzana

Post by Zuzana Thu Feb 22, 2007 7:35 am

MacRua wrote:Shane did have a go at banjo, bodhran and casio keys... Besides guitar.

And at accordion! Only he didn't realize you dont play it by pouring wine all over it... ;)
[quote="MacRua"]Shane did have a go at banjo, bodhran and casio keys... Besides guitar.[/quote]
And at accordion! Only he didn't realize you dont play it by pouring wine all over it... ;)

Top

  • Board index
  • The team • Delete all board cookies • All times are UTC


Powered by phpBB
Content © copyright the original authors unless otherwise indicated